Early American Colonial Currency: The Pine Tree Shilling

April 12, 2024

In the early days of British colonial settlement in North America, there was an acute shortage of official British currency circulating in the colonies. This lack of a reliable medium of exchange significantly hampered economic growth and trade. To remedy this situation, the Massachusetts Bay Colony took an unprecedented step in 1652 by establishing the first colonial mint and beginning the production of its own official coinage - the famous Pine Tree Shilling.

The Pine Tree derived its name from the distinct pine tree design stamped on the reverse side, while the obverse bore the inscription "Massachusetts" surrounding a basic ring. These crudely manufactured silver coins were struck in several denominations including the shilling, sixpence, and threepence. Though the British Crown had not authorized or approved this new currency, the colonial Massachusetts government decided the economic needs justified the move.

Initially, the Pine Tree Shillings maintained full value comparable to their British counterparts. However, due to their unstandardized striking and the ongoing silver shortage, the coins were frequently overstruck and their silver content diminished over time. This caused the Pine Tree currency to devalue versus sterling over the decades it was minted from 1652 to around 1682.

Despite this devaluation, the Pine Tree coinage represented an important first step towards economic independence for the Massachusetts colonists. The ready supply of this currency facilitated vital trade and economic expansion at a critical juncture of colonial development. Its production also clearly demonstrated the willingness of colonial governments to exercise autonomy over monetary policy apart from the mother country when circumstances demanded it.

Not surprisingly, the unilateral decision to mint colonial currency was viewed as an act of defiance by the British authorities. However, rather than taking direct punitive action against Massachusetts, the Crown opted for a more measured response. No colonial mint workers were arrested or put on trial for producing the illegal Pine Tree tender.

Instead, the British asserted their control over colonial money by revoking the Massachusetts mint's legal status and right to coin money in 1686. From that point forward, production of the Pine Tree coins ceased under threat of strict penalties.

Despite this crackdown, the Pine Tree Shillings were allowed to remain in circulation and trade alongside British sterling for several more decades until being finally demonetized early in the 18th century. So while the British government reasserted its prerogative over colonial currency, it pragmatically accepted the Pine Tree coinage as a temporary solution to a very real shortage of money in Massachusetts.

From a historical perspective, the Pine Tree Shilling can be viewed as an early predecessor to the modern U.S. dollar and first representational currency for British North America. While its lifespan was relatively brief, the significance of this pioneering colonial money should not be underestimated. The Pine Tree coins met an urgent need for currency, enabled colonial commerce to flourish, and foreshadowed the creation of an independent American economic system in the centuries to come.

Through this revolutionary act of minting the Pine Tree Shilling, the Massachusetts colonists laid the groundwork for eventual financial independence from Britain. This spirit of self-determination and self-government in monetary affairs reflected the growing desire for fuller autonomy that would ultimately lead to outright revolution and the birth of the United States as a new nation in 1776. The origins of this journey towards "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness" can be traced back to the often overlooked but tremendously important Pine Tree Shilling of the 17th century.